OU students can meet a postgraduate course’s grade requirements and still be unable to complete an application because they cannot obtain the required academic references.
An academic reference is a written assessment from an academic who knows the applicant’s assessed work. It normally comments on matters such as the applicant’s academic ability, research and writing skills, intellectual independence, performance in relation to other students, and suitability for postgraduate study.
That is different from an institutional reference, which primarily confirms factual information such as registration, modules studied and grades received. The OU’s current central reference appears to be an institutional or hybrid reference. It may confirm a student’s academic record, but it does not necessarily provide the personal academic assessment that other universities require, and only counts as one submission.
This distinction matters because postgraduate courses often specify that the referee must be an academic who is familiar with the applicant’s work. For example:
- the University of Cambridge’s LLM and MCL require two academic referees from applicants who are currently studying;
- UCL’s LLM requires an academic reference from someone familiar with the applicant’s academic ability and research and writing skills;
- Cardiff University’s MPhil in Law requires two academic references and states that incomplete applications will not be considered;
- the University of York’s Law MA by research lists two academic references as mandatory;
- York St John University’s Law MRes requires two academic references, both of which must arrive before the application is reviewed; and
- Oxford’s BCL requires three referees overall and strongly prefers academic references.
These requirements create a practical gateway. Consider an OU student who is on course for a first-class LLB and meets the grade requirement for a master’s course. The course requires two academic referees. If the student’s tutors decline, are unavailable or do not know the student’s work well enough, the student may be unable to provide the required references. A central reference confirming modules and grades may not meet the receiving university’s criteria. The application may therefore remain incomplete or never be considered.
The student has not been rejected because of their academic ability. They have been prevented from reaching the stage at which their academic merit can be assessed.
Under the current arrangements, access to an academic reference depends heavily on individual tutors’ discretion. A tutor may agree or decline. There is no reliable guarantee that another suitable academic will be appointed if the tutor refuses, is unavailable or lacks enough knowledge of the student’s work.
This is why luck becomes a factor. A student’s opportunity to apply may depend on:
- which tutor they happen to be allocated;
- whether they retain the same tutor for long enough to develop an academic relationship;
- how much individual contact that tutor offers;
- whether the tutor is available when applications open;
- whether the tutor is willing to act as a referee; and
- whether the student happens to have two or three tutors willing to provide separate references.
Two students with the same grades and comparable academic ability may therefore have different opportunities. One may have tutors who agree to provide detailed references. The other may have tutors who decline or say that they do not know the student well enough. The difference is personal discretion and tutor allocation rather than academic merit.
This is especially serious for distance learners. OU students may have limited direct contact with tutors, may change tutors between modules and may not have a dissertation supervisor or personal tutor who follows their academic development over several years. The University cannot rely on individual relationships while structuring its teaching in a way that may make those relationships difficult to develop.
I am asking Open SU to seek a formal change to OU policy so that students and graduates have a reliable route to the number and type of academic references required by their intended postgraduate course.
The policy should:
- create an entitlement for students and graduates with assessed OU work to obtain the number and type of academic references required by the receiving course;
- require the OU to appoint another suitable academic when a tutor declines, is unavailable or does not know the student’s work well enough;
- give students planning postgraduate study named academic contacts who have taught, supervised or assessed their work;
- provide sufficient academic contact for those academics to make an informed assessment;
- require references to address the receiving institution’s published criteria, including academic ability, research and writing skills, and suitability for further study;
- set clear service standards, including acknowledgement within two working days, allocation of referees within five working days and submission within 15 working days;
- provide urgent escalation where an application deadline is approaching;
- provide an independent review where the OU refuses or fails to arrange a suitable reference; and
- introduce immediate arrangements for current students and graduates who already lack suitable referees.
Academic staff should remain free to give an honest assessment of a student’s work. The policy change concerns access to that assessment. The University should take responsibility for ensuring that an appropriate academic provides it, rather than leaving access to individual willingness and chance.
The OU’s commitment to open access should extend beyond admission to an undergraduate degree. It should also give OU students a fair opportunity to submit complete postgraduate applications and have their academic merit considered.